So only trans people get to have an opinion on somebody’s intent? Do you think that all trans people always agree on what is and isn’t transphobic? How do you square that with the trans people who also don’t believe Rowling is transphobic? Do they get to tell you what is and is not transphobic?

What even makes you think I’m trying to tell trans people what is and isn’t transphobic? Or do you just mean that I’m not allowed to have an opinion on whether Rowling (who isn’t trans) is being portrayed fairly.

I’m wide open to criticism, or to have you point out what I’m missing. I’m genuinely here to listen if you’re interested in having an actual conversation, just as I have been with numerous other trans people before expressing my thoughts. Or is this just an attempt to silence somebody with the old “you just don’t get it,” routine?